SMS and email marketing work best as one plan with a split of jobs. Email carries almost everything, because it is cheap enough to send to every buyer and long enough to sell. SMS carries the few messages a buyer needs within the hour, sent only to people who gave written consent to texts.
For a seller who buys traffic, that usually means email first and one text as the follow-up: an abandoned checkout email after an hour, a text a few hours later if the order still hasn't landed, and both stop when it does.
If a message can wait until tomorrow morning, I send it by email.
Most of the guides ranking for this topic are written by companies that sell one channel or both, and they tend to end with "use more of it". A seller running paid traffic has a different problem. You already paid for the click, the buyer already gave you an email and maybe a phone number, and the question is which of the two to spend on for each message.
I spent nine years as CTO of a direct-response company, and the line on our about page that still stings is "Recovery calls that didn't fire." Recovery emails and texts fail the same quiet way. Usually the cause is two tools that don't know about each other, so one sends while the other stays silent, or both send at once.
SMS vs email marketing: cost, length and consent
The two channels differ most on price, and the price decides most of the plan. Here is one send to 10,000 people at the public list prices of two common senders, read on 18 November 2026. Your provider and plan will differ; the ratio is what matters.
| One send to 10,000 people | Price used | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Email through Amazon SES (Essentials plan) | $0.16 per 1,000 emails | 10 × $0.16 = $1.60 |
| One-segment text through Twilio, long code, US | $0.0083 per segment, plus a carrier fee of $0.0035 (AT&T) to $0.0045 (T-Mobile) | 10,000 × $0.0118 = $118, up to 10,000 × $0.0128 = $128 |
So a text costs 75 to 80 times what an email costs, before you count the work of getting SMS consent. That gap is the whole argument for giving texts only the messages that can't wait.

- Length. An email can carry a long offer, a bonus explanation or an order summary. A text should fit one segment, 160 plain characters, with one link; an emoji or a long URL can push it to three segments and triple the cost.
- Consent. Marketing email in the US is opt-out. Automated marketing texts need written consent first (more on both below).
- Reach. Almost every checkout asks for an email. Only the ones who tick an SMS box can get marketing texts, so the text list is always the smaller one.
Vendor pages quote open rates for texts that nobody outside the vendor can check. I wouldn't plan around them. What you can check is your own sales per send, and that comes later in this post.
Which message goes on which channel
One question sorts almost every message: does the buyer need this within the hour? If yes, and they agreed to texts, text it. Everything else goes by email, where it costs a fraction and has room to explain.

| Message in a paid-traffic funnel | SMS | |
|---|---|---|
| Order receipt, login or access details | Always | Only a short "check your inbox" if access is urgent |
| Abandoned checkout | First, after about an hour | One follow-up a few hours later, if still unpaid |
| Failed payment on a rebill | First, with the update-card link | A reminder before the next retry |
| Shipping and delivery updates | Yes | Yes, if the buyer asked for them |
| Reorder reminder for a consumable | Yes | For repeat buyers who opted in |
| Offers, launches, Black Friday early access | The full offer | A few times a year, short |
| Content, stories, education | Yes | No |
The rows overlap on purpose: shipping news can go on both. A failed rebill is the one I'd watch most closely. It is money you already earned, the buyer usually didn't mean to churn, and a text the day before the retry reaches them while the card is still in their wallet. That kind of loss has a name, involuntary churn, and most of it is a reminder problem.
Run SMS and email as one sequence
The usual setup has an email tool and an SMS tool, each with its own abandoned checkout flow. Picture a buyer who leaves a checkout at 8 p.m. At 9 they get the email and the text in the same minute, both saying "you left something behind". At 9:05 they pay, and at 9 the next morning the SMS tool, which never heard about the order, texts them a discount.
That buyer paid full price and was then offered less. Build the follow-up as one sequence instead, started by the checkout and stopped by the order:

- Hour 1, email. A link back to the same checkout, with the cart as they left it.
- Hour 4, one text. Only if the order hasn't landed and the buyer ticked the SMS box. Brand name, one line, the same link.
- Day 1, second email. Answer the doubt that stops most buyers on that offer: shipping time, the guarantee, how the subscription works.
- Day 2, call center. For high-value carts only, if you run one.
Before each step, check that the order still hasn't arrived, in whatever tool sends it. That single check is what keeps the sequence from texting a buyer who already paid. The timings are where I'd start, and worth testing against your own offer.
The arithmetic, with illustrative numbers: 2,000 abandoned checkouts a month cost $0.32 to email. If 1,700 are still unpaid at hour 4, the texts cost $20 to $22. If the text brings back 17 orders at $59, that is $1,003 in sales for about $1.20 to $1.30 of texting per order. Texting all 2,000 at hour 1, before the email had a chance, would have spent more on buyers who were coming back anyway.
Consent and opt-outs for each channel
The two channels run on different US rules. Marketing email is opt-out under CAN-SPAM, while automated marketing texts need written consent first under the TCPA. So the SMS box sits on its own, unchecked, and each channel keeps its own suppression list: a STOP ends texts, an unsubscribe ends email. The checkbox wording, the confirmation text, STOP handling and A2P 10DLC registration are in SMS marketing best practices, and the Gmail and Yahoo sender rules are in email marketing campaigns.
Count the sales per channel
Opens and clicks flatter both channels. Tag every link with UTM parameters (utm_source=email or sms, utm_campaign=the send) and compare sends on two numbers.
- Revenue per recipient: sales from the send divided by the people who got it.
- Cost per order: what the send cost divided by the orders it brought. A text can win on revenue per recipient and still lose here.
For a sequence, hold out a small random holdout group that gets neither message. Some buyers come back on their own, and without a holdout every one of them gets counted as a win for the email or the text that happened to reach them first.
SMS and email marketing in ElasticFunnels
In ElasticFunnels the email and the text can sit in one automation, started by what happened in the funnel, with links counted per channel in the UTM Performance report. The step-by-step setup, with a clip for each step, is in the Academy tutorial how to create an email or SMS campaign. Every feature is on every plan.
- Never send the same message on both channels in the same minute. The text adds cost and the second copy adds nothing.
- Put the failed-rebill reminder on SMS before you put any promotion there. It recovers money the buyer already agreed to pay.
- Abandon your own checkout once a month and pay on the second message. If the third one still arrives, the stop check is broken.
- Keep the SMS list small and earned. A thousand buyers who ticked the box on purpose are worth more than a big list you can't prove.
Email is the default for nearly every message. Texts are the expensive, fast channel you save for the moments a buyer would want to hear from you within the hour. Wire them into one sequence that knows when the order lands, and you'll send fewer texts and recover more of the checkouts you already paid to get.



